I’m terrified of the moment when my form slips from their current halo-wearing status. To this end I’ve been instigating a Friday afternoon ritual where we sit in a circle and do some kind of activity vaguely aiming to instil a sense pride and responsibility for what we have achieved so far as 7B. Last week was bullying. Yesterday, the more prickly issue of reacting appropriately to the achievements of others and ourselves.
In pairs they were given a set of possible sentences they would (honestly) like to say to a friend whose test result was better than theirs. Each pair then screwed up their chosen statement, threw it into the middle of the circle and grabbed another from a different pair. The statements ranged from ‘Well done – you deserved it’ to ‘It’s not fair, I’m better than you!’, and – luckily – 7B were generally honest and most pairs chose statements closer to the latter than the former. We repeated the process imaging that this time WE had scored highest and thinking about what we would say to the unlucky runner-up. With a similar range of statements available, every pair but one admitted that they would console the unhappy loser with a sensitive: ‘WHO THE MAN!!!’
As well as the amusing experience of 22 eleven-year-olds reveled in the unveiling of their collective inner b******d, the more serious goal of this enterprise was to acknowledge how difficult it is to deal with disappointment, especially when that disappointment can be directly correlated to another’s success. To my mind, the only way to prevent the inevitable baiting of high-achievers in a form is to accept that none of us are immune to feeling resentment towards others, or to the urge to crow about our achievements from the roof-tops. The problem is, kids are too often told that they shouldn’t have these feelings; that the feelings themselves are wrong.
As I tried to emphasise to my form, the stuff they feel is OK. In fact, it’s good insofar that it demonstrates ambition and determination. But the trick is to manage their emotions in a way which shows respect for others and respect for themselves. Having all seen each other’s secret thoughts about achievement, I hope they found this easier to understand. Time to get back to polishing those halos …